top of page

How Being A Tenant Improved My Landlord Game - Part 2

11 minutes ago
7 min read
Run Down Cottage
Run Down Cottage

I must confess my secret passion, and what I've been up to since 2018 or so. I've buy abandoned and derelict places, and fix them up and rent them out, in Northern Ontario.


Lac Gerard "Campground"

I was on Facebook Marketplace, when I came upon an ad for a cottage for sale for $22,000 I contacted the guy, and he told me I was required to speak to the landowner and apply. I loved the owner, a lovely lady in her 70's. This was a cottage on a leased lot. You own the cottage and they own the land.


The guy who owned the cottage then decided to raise the price from $22,000 to $26,000 and I declined to continue the purchase process. I called the landlord back to let her know, and she told me that she and the tenant were going to the Landlord and Tenant Board.


At the LTB hearing they came to some arrangement, and the landowner bought the cottage and called me the very next day, to sell me the cottage at $22,000. I accepted and became a tenant... again.


After the Renovation
After the Renovation

The Offer to Buy "The Campground"

I got on with the owner of the place very well, and she was planning to retire. There were some issues with the campground which no longer operated as a campground, but was this collection of small houses and a few all year long camper trailers.


She wanted $400,000 for the place, which in retrospect was a great deal, but I was 10 hours away and having a baby (he's 2 now).


Due to the issues with the septic and water, the amount had to be paid in cash. In any case I declined, which I would later regret in spades, but.... only hindsight is 20/20.


In Come the New Owners: Stephen and Marlene Wagler


June 1 2026, the new owners take over the site, and they started off with an... illegal rent increase on all the tenants. At the time I didn't care, the rent went from Annual $750 to $1100. I ended up paying the amount and moving on, not really wanting to make an issue when there is none.


My intention with the cottage was to rent it out short/medium term until I could find a full time tenant, and move on to the next project. Decent housing is hard to find up North and it's a beautiful quiet place to live, by the lake so fishing and hunting and fun. I wouldn't mind living there myself one day.


The cottage I first got was renovated and really nice so I was hunting for a new project.


Cottage 2 is purchased


The Second Cottage
The Second Cottage

This cottage had been purchased just prior to the new owner taking over. I had noticed another cottage on Facebook Marketplace for $11,500 this time, and I contacted the seller and in the process of looking at the place it was sold. So I spoke to the former owner of the place, and said to her I had just missed my chance and she said that she had just received the keys back for the above lovely cottage.


The highlights of this cottage included no kitchen, no bathroom, no flooring, no windows, no heat source. But... the electricity was still on, and that's a 6-7 month wait to get the power turned on by Hydro One and a whole process. I wasn't going to keep any of the kitchen, bathroom anyway so I saved myself some demo costs and a few trips to the dump.


So a couple weeks after that...


Cottage 3 is purchased


This one I just couldn't say no to because it was waterfront and it was cute, but it had no electricity and so I knew that would take a few months to hook it back up again. I was contacted by the seller, and I couldn't say no and that same day I sent the seller the money. I figured once the first one was done I would have another project already in the runway.


Some people like new cars, but apparently I have an issue with run down cottage acquisitions. I've never heard of Cottages Anonymous so I'm fine.




And then like any other person with a cottage issue, I was told there was an abandoned cottage right next to the second cottage I bought and so I bought....


Cottage 4 Purchase


Cottage 4 - Overgrown mess
Cottage 4 - Overgrown mess

You might think I'm a rich bitch or something, but I truly am not. At all. The most I paid for these cottages is $22,000 and the least I paid was $3000. Cottage 4 had been for sale for 4 years and there are around 10 cottages still for sale...


You'd think that the new owner would be overjoyed that someone is fixing these derelict cottages up, and doing something with them but you would be wrong. Why? I'm not sure.


Let the PROBLEMS begin


Land lease cottages are not sold like regular cottages. The lease is assigned. Land lease landlords are not like other landlords either. From what I can determine they are a bunch of micromanaging mental cases. I base this on my study of case law in land lease communities.


Land Lease communities been covered under the Tenant Protection Act since 1992 and landlords are still playing games. Just this year up the street from my cottage on Remi Lake the landlord was claiming her land lease community was covered under the Commercial Tenancies Act. Larabie v Crickard  


When I bought Cottage 3, I submitted my application to the owner's email, and they didn't reply for over a month. Upon request of assignment of the lease and receipt of the application the landlord has 15 days to file an application defending their reasons for not wanting you as a tenant and if they do not, you automatically become a tenant.


That's when the truth of the new owner's intentions came out. When he did get back to replying to the email the seller and I had sent him, he wanted $2400 per year in rent and told us about his market survey of area land lease communities. Apparently "everyone else" was paying a lot more and he wanted more rent as well. Don't we all?


One Year Rule

One year after you pay a rent, it becomes the legal rent. That is the new rule about rents, so after hearing about the intentions to raise the rent to $2400, I heartily disagreed. So while I didn't care too much about $350 per year, a 3 fold rent increase seemed outrageous.


Around the end of July he called me because I sent an email asking when the septic would be fixed/upgraded, and he did not have an answer about that, said he didn't realize it was his obligation and that's when the problems really began...


Reporting me to the Building Department of the Town


The day after the conversation I had with the owner Stephen Wagler, the site manager, Mike Gillis, who had been very happy to hang out and smoke dope with one of the construction crew we'd named "Whiskey Princess" reported us to the town for building without a building permit like everybody else in the middle of nowhere.


Then he wouldn't give me authorization to get a building permit and I was not allowed to get a building permit by the town without the authorization, and so now that forced me to make an Application to the Court, which is ongoing.


Let the Litigation at the LTB begin


This part is super annoying, I decided to start bringing the Owner to the LTB for illegal rent increases.


I was far from alone, other tenants had beat me to it, there was a case in July stating the Act Applied, and a lot more since then.


So after years of going to the LTB on behalf of landlords, I was put in this situation where I'm going to the LTB as a tenant, and it's really pissing me off.


Every case is for $350.... And takes hours and hours and now the Landlord isn't even showing up.


Lessons Learned


I'm still working on this one to be honest, I don't know how many times I've recommended the owner get legal advice, I just want the guy to follow the law of this province but he just continues to try to escalate.


1 - I already know how hard it is to normalize relationships with someone when you've sued them 8+ times. It's impossible.


2 - Land Lease communities can be a nightmare and as far as I can tell most landlords know nothing about the RTA.


3 - Building permits on a 50 year old cottage that was built by some guy, are not easy or quick. In Rural areas, no one is there to do drawings, and if they are prices are astronomical. It's hard to spend 12K on plans for a $3000 cottage to get a building permit. Unfortunately I have decided to do this myself and I'm awful. Good thing I have a day job.


4 - All this legal bullshit will distract you from whatever you do to make money to support yourself, it's a real drain and a real time sink.


5 - Even now I kind of feel bad for the guy, he's done a lot of illegal things, including the rent increase, including threatening people working with immigration and police, including sending rude and threatening emails and so more litigation is in his future from me.


I guess the ultimate lesson for landlords is if you have a litigious tenant or a tenant who knows the law better than you, stop escalating!


We're professionals, and every time you write an email before pressing send think to yourself, if an adjudicator saw this, what would they think?


Just assume you are being recorded, during inspections, during any tenant interactions, and ACT ACCORDINGLY.


I do manage properties with litigious tenants and I've deescalated so many of these tenants, because I don't react, I don't engage emotionally, and I don't act unprofessionally even when people are behaving like complete terrors.


I don't know this situation will end, but I'm hopeful we can eventually work things out. After all, I have an eye on another waterfront cottage. (No I'm not joking)


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page